archited
Senior Member
Now that is ridiculous -- who can surmise what elements will be in play 50 years out let alone 200 to 300 years -- Planners with too much time on their hands.
Accurately? It's not possible. It's more of a thought experiment using assumptions and broad estimates. When I was a planner working for Fortis I used to do this to try and forecast how long it would take to build out gas infrastructure say, into the interior. But there are far too many variables to even forecast beyond 5 years unfortunately.Now that is ridiculous -- who can surmise what elements will be in play 50 years out let alone 200 to 300 years -- Planners with too much time on their hands.
I agree, thanks for saying what I was thinking too.Now that is ridiculous -- who can surmise what elements will be in play 50 years out let alone 200 to 300 years -- Planners with too much time on their hands.
You mean I have to put up with construction downtown for another 200 years. I don’t know if I can take it.The Downtown design/zoning study had '200-300 years' of land/FAR supply in the core.
This all sounds sort of nice, but what does it really mean? For instance "renew the memory of heritage buildings, districts and landscapes". Are they going to put up another plaque or something?From May 16, 2023 EDC Minutes:
C.2 Warehouse Park Sarah Stephenson- COE Motion of Non- support: D. Brown Seconded: N. Pryce While the Committee supports the development of the park space, it is suggested that at this stage of project development there should be further design consideration to the following:
● ‘Warehouse Park aims to respect, contribute, and renew the memory or heritage of buildings, districts and landscapes’ A further refinement of essences and character components (e.g., playground/play areas, the form of structures/canopies, hard surfaces, soft landscape, site furniture, lighting, warming/fireplaces, northern light arbor structure, public art and other features) should be considered to better reflect and interpret the Warehouse District and other important cultural/indigenous ‘memories’ to establish a unique sense of place for Warehouse Park that is different than other contemporary Edmonton park spaces. (Principle C2)
● ‘Indigenous vegetation is promoted to provide habitat and connectivity for wildlife in and through the park.’A further refinement on the use and arrangement of indigenous (originating or occurring naturally in Alberta or Edmonton) plantings should be considered to better reflect the Edmonton/Alberta cultural landscape and establish a more ecological and sustainable landscape.
● Consider incorporating more design elements that meaningfully address/represent the cultural significance of the area to indigenous communities. Themes should be represented in the form, function, and finish (materiality) of the built work - creating spaces and functional elements with appropriate consultation with indigenous communities. Themes should genuinely facilitate use and sense of ownership of the space by indigenous communities, rather than just provide a visual representation of cultural motifs (murals, symbols, "plop art").
For the Motion: N. Pryce, J. Candlish, M. Tindall, D. Brown, J. Monfries, C. Dorward Against the Motion: K. Dieterman, T. Ziola, E. Dunn, J. Mills CARRIED
This is something I've been suggesting for some time. Though there were some really cool homes and buildings in the area. Much of their history is unknown to the general public and it would be really cool to have some monuments to their memory in the form of historical monuments scattered on the various lots. The area will feel relatively new and modern once the area is built out, and it'll be easy to forget that there's been a hundred years of lives, careers, and businesses that were silently demolished in the area over the past 30 years.This all sounds sort of nice, but what does it really mean? For instance "renew the memory of heritage buildings, districts and landscapes". Are they going to put up another plaque or something?
The way the city does it quality doesn't go up, it just takes longerNothing the city does seems to go quickly. One would hope taking time would improve the outcome, but based on other projects not so sure about that.