IanO
Superstar
Only if they are world-class iconic.
Yes, this is a dilemma, particularly if those suburban communities are close enough and large enough to attract commuters.Sorry to say @Platinum107 you can't stop suburban sprawl unless the City you are referring to has geographic restrictions (e.g. Vancouver or San Francisco). If you establish a green belt in a City like Edmonton. suburbs will simply leapfrog the barrier and start anew on the other side. Growth in cities like Leduc, Spruce Grove, and Sherwood Park are examples of growth beyond boundaries. In short, you can't mandate peoples living preferences.
Maybe the city departments also need to talk to each other and not work at cross purposes. For instance, we now seem to have on street parking bans for weeks and weeks on end for snow clearing, so anyone who didn't already have a two car garage probably really wants one now.Have you read the book Nudge? Its a great illustration of the role of city politics i think.
We can't just show, we also can't coerce, but we can nudge. The premise of the book is that most of us actually can't make the best decisions for ourselves and are best aided by experts creating systems that nudge us towards more ideal outcomes. They give examples in health care, investing and saving, food and diet, etc. I think urban planning is similar. I actually don't believe most people want a detached house, yard and 2 car garage. So designing a better city, paired with nudging then towards better choices is key.
An example, redo property taxes to factor in size, not just value. Incentivize non car modes. Give first time buyer credits to mature and infill homes. Free or cheap transit for TOD. Mileage taxes. Better education to teens and uni students on housing types and urban planning. Etc.
Maybe not a new dictionary, but im sure a reading of the book would be interesting! Those are very gentle nudges. You can inspire someone to eat healthy by showing commercials of fit and attractive people....or, you can create laws about displaying calories on menus and ensuring health requirements in school cafeterias. Those are stronger nudges vs inspiration.@thommyjo if "showing by example", "following trends", and "building possibilities" aren't "nudges" then I need a new dictionary. Zoning for years now has been misguided and wrong-headed -- so "Planning" is good now but wasn't in the past? Planners historically have been as trend-seeking as fashion designers in the clothing industry -- I could give a very long list of examples.
I don't think compensation should be offered UNLESS there are additional or unexpected delays.
Here are some better 'before' photos that I took today.Fort Saskatchewan is getting a street redone downtown, and it'll include a pretty significant sidewalk expansion.
Right now, 103rd street has narrow sidewalks, with some sections missing entirely.
View attachment 392360View attachment 392361View attachment 392362
The new design, which will be constructed this year, widens the sidewalks by 3m (on the east half) and 1.5/1.7m (on the west half, nearest to the green apartment building). On top of that, they're also putting in rows of trees that separate pedestrians and vehicle traffic, like we already see along 100 Ave downtown.
View attachment 392366View attachment 392367
So, the sidewalk should look something like this (but not as fancy, and a bit narrower in parts).
View attachment 392370