archited
Senior Member
There's no convincing -- so I'll stop now.
Not to be rude, but you recognize these exist all over the city already, right? Curb bulbs and street planters aren't a new thing. I'm sure they can figure it out againI am not an expert gardener, but I do know that of the hundreds of plants to choose from only a few will live and thrive in the salty soils alongside a road. I think we would already have them by now if it was easy to do.
I'm not against the idea of gardens, I like them very much. If they can make it financially worthwhile, go for it!
Also I doubt its 40% of the paved surface...maybe 20-30? Hard to tell. But if you're so worried about proportional allocation of street space to mode of transportation, you're going to hate hearing about our downtownIf there is anything that could do with a little value engineering, this would be it. How much will it cost to plant those gardens every year, are volunteers going to do that? The garden in the middle should just be grass with a tree in the middle. I hope the foot and bike traffic is busy enough to account for 40% of the total paved surface area dedicated towards them (the Netherlands have over 10x the traffic). What will the maintenance budget for the roundabout be like 10 years from now? This is being proposed for a location that isn't even prominent within the city.
Here's the signalized version of that intersection, as well as the pros and cons of each option.Hello Gorgeous!
View attachment 374986
This is a proposed option for 90 Street and 132 Avenue. Yes, this is Edmonton! There are several schools along 132ave in this area including Queen E and O'Leary High Schools (I'm a Spartans grad!) So providing safe active transportation options like this znd traffic calming is right on the money.
More cool plans located here regarding 132 Ave renewal:
132 Avenue Renewal | City of Edmonton
Collector Renewal construction is underway on 132 Avenue between Fort Road and 127 Street.www.edmonton.ca
I am more concerned about how much it will cost to maintain the roundabout than anything else, and I am aware that the amount of space allotted for bicycles may be lower than 40% but I am focusing on only the roundabout. I already know what is going on downtown.Also I doubt its 40% of the paved surface...maybe 20-30? Hard to tell. But if you're so worried about proportional allocation of street space to mode of transportation, you're going to hate hearing about our downtown
I went to high school on 132 Ave and I can say that the area is sorely lacking in sidewalk area at the moment, especially around the bus stops. I'd rather have sidewalks/bikelanes that are a bit too wide than grass that will quickly die and turn into ugly desire paths.I hope the foot and bike traffic is busy enough to account for 40% of the total paved surface area dedicated towards them (the Netherlands have over 10x the traffic).
Wait until you hear about the costs of a car dependent city. Projects like this move us closer to the necessary future we're pursuing.I am more concerned about how much it will cost to maintain the roundabout than anything else, and I am aware that the amount of space allotted for bicycles may be lower than 40% but I am focusing on only the roundabout. I already know what is going on downtown.