Valley Line LRT | TransEd/Marigold | City of Edmonton

I could see the Transit Union essentially demand crossing arms at the Whitemud, 51st Ave, Roper Rd, and McIntyre Rd intersections. I don't particularly care what the impact on vehicle traffic would be. Protecting occupants from idiots in large vehicles is more important.

The insurance claim on this one today is gonna be big for the trucking company.
 
I could see the Transit Union essentially demand crossing arms at the Whitemud, 51st Ave, Roper Rd, and McIntyre Rd intersections. I don't particularly care what the impact on vehicle traffic would be. Protecting occupants from idiots in large vehicles is more important.

The insurance claim on this one today is gonna be big for the trucking company.
Yeah I can't imagine the cost today. The size of the crane they had to bring in to right the train was substantial.
 
I could see the Transit Union essentially demand crossing arms at the Whitemud, 51st Ave, Roper Rd, and McIntyre Rd intersections. I don't particularly care what the impact on vehicle traffic would be. Protecting occupants from idiots in large vehicles is more important.

The insurance claim on this one today is gonna be big for the trucking company.
They will declare bankruptcy
 
if the driver is already running a light, larger signs will not help.

thank you for the smart ass reply...

Hardly. More visibility for that "no right turn on red" sign should help.
Well I have an interesting idea, Install two arms across both lanes protecting the tracks, light them up like a van halen concert (no pyro though), timed to the lrt/traffic lights. Arms start to rise at the orange light, up for green, BUT we also install rumble strips up the whitemud/75th off ramp, about 4 sets to wake up people
 
I could see the Transit Union essentially demand crossing arms at the Whitemud, 51st Ave, Roper Rd, and McIntyre Rd intersections.
As far as I know TransEd isn't unionized. I believe ATU was able to get On Demand unionized however.
 
Last edited:
Well I have an interesting idea, Install two arms across both lanes protecting the tracks, light them up like a van halen concert (no pyro though), timed to the lrt/traffic lights. Arms start to rise at the orange light, up for green, BUT we also install rumble strips up the whitemud/75th off ramp, about 4 sets to wake up people
This set up is actually used at Southgate for the buses exiting from Southgate on the southside. Not exactly the same thing, but the gates are always down protecting the tracks, except when the buses have a green light. Granted, they aren't lit up at all in fact. No flashing red lights, just the traffic lights, crossing gate and a standard crossbuck.
 
It may not be time just yet, but I hope some time soon the city bites the bullet and admits that no crossing arms at intersections was a failure. Put away the pride and just fix the problem

I would think the cost is a bigger barrier than pride.
 
Why not ban all right hand turns? It's a safty issue across the city. I have almost been hit walking Downtown many times.
That will be a very tough habit for drivers to break.

Maybe the city can launch an exciting new career opportunity to help lower Edmonton's unemployment?

1000004857.jpg
 
Why not ban all right hand turns? It's a safty issue across the city. I have almost been hit walking Downtown many times.
Unfortunately that's provincial level and there is no way the UCP is going to agree to it. However vastly increasing the number of NO-Right-on-Red lights across the city where there are no slip lanes present might help in the longer run. Not nearly as cost effective as a law change to No Right on Red due to the cost of all the signage and upgrades to lights but the city can only due so much.
 
It may not be time just yet, but I hope some time soon the city bites the bullet and admits that no crossing arms at intersections was a failure. Put away the pride and just fix the problem
From what I understand its actually the delay to drivers that they don't want. Avoiding the dead time at intersections that drivers have to wait for the arms to drop before the train comes and then waiting for them to raise after the train leaves was a big motivator for this style of intersection. Now, I think Edmonton drivers have proven they aren't smart enough to deserve that so arms must be considered.
 
There’s this new advocacy group called Edmonton Transit Riders, which has spoken in City Council in the past about things like fare gates. I’ll be checking them out at their launch party in October and seeing if there will be opportunities to voice our desire for boom gates at intersections south of Davies Station. Maybe they’ll give it a platform in front of City Hall.
The chair of ETR seems to have a plan under consideration for crossing arms.
 
I'd recommend a speed limit sign for the off-ramp on Whitemud, to encourage drivers to slow down. Also, it might be useful to add LED "No right turn" signs, either at before the tracks, or before the right turns leading to the tracks.
 

Back
Top