News   Apr 03, 2020
 9.1K     3 
News   Apr 02, 2020
 10K     0 
News   Apr 02, 2020
 3.3K     0 

Rethinking the Entrances to Edmonton

yeggator

Active Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 18, 2021
Messages
834
Reaction score
2,880
So I was inspired to make this thread because I use Gateway Boulevard/Calgary Trail to commute to and from work every day, and with how much traffic's grown, it's such a pain in the ass it use these roadways. I also think it doesn't give a great first impression of the city as the main entrance from the international airport and places like Calgary. When you reach the first stoplight on Gateway, you get to bear witness to a frequently backed up at-grade railroad crossing with a giant Wendy's sign behind it, and a whole lot of cluttered commercial buildings that butt right up against the roadway on both sides. It's such a small-town entrance for the capital of the highest-HDI region on the continent. And since I mentioned Calgary, I always thought it's nice that you can theoretically travel from the QE2 entrance to the city up to Downtown in a wide-open, fairly naturalized free-flow right-of-way (even if, in practice, you'll get stuck in traffic 99% of the time).

Now, I'd never advocate for all the destruction required to plow a freeway straight to downtown, but you could get most of the way there by upgrading 91st Street to a freeway (which already has nice naturalized greenery along the ROW). Then, with all the capacity you free up on Gateway and Calgary Trail, turn them bidirectional arterials (cause unidirectional couplets are stupid) and add BRT and active transportation along Calgary Trail. Then, you funnel traffic from the 91st Street freeway onto Argyll, from which they can access DT by Gateway/Walterdale or 109th/High Level (both bridges becoming bidirectional). Make some aesthetic improvements and you now have a proper north-south transportation spine south of the river that accommodates several modes, moves them quickly and is a more fitting entrance to the big city. And don't forget about grade-separating the railway for high-speed rail!
 
Last edited:
1756102725020.png
 
Last edited:
Lots of this makes sense. I also think we just need some new signs to welcome people to our city. Our current highway/entrance ones suck. As does the airport experience of driving into the city.

Nicer art, lighting, planters/landscaping.
 
Lots of this makes sense. I also think we just need some new signs to welcome people to our city. Our current highway/entrance ones suck. As does the airport experience of driving into the city.
I’d love for our highway entrance signs to have the same design motifs as city hall. Blue-tinted glass and steel diamond-covered pyramids, the city logo in dark metal lettering against sandstone, and an updated skyline motif with Walterdale, the Leg, Epcor Tower and Stantec Tower
 
Discussing Gene Dub’s design for entrance markers from 2007:

https://blog.mastermaq.ca/tag/entrance-signs/

You have to love the quote from Tod Babiak coming on almost two decades ago now:

“In 10 years, we won’t remember the potholes of 2007. But giant pyramids on each end of the city could be there, still inspiring debate.”

“If we continue to configure our priorities, as a community, around a reflexive, mean- spirited and frankly stupid hostility to cultural spending, the filled potholes will allow a lot of very smooth one-way trips out of this cold, efficient province.”
 
Entrance gimmicks are a sign of desperation, who wants to see the world's largest paperclip?
 
You have to love the quote from Tod Babiak coming on almost two decades ago now:

“In 10 years, we won’t remember the potholes of 2007. But giant pyramids on each end of the city could be there, still inspiring debate.”

“If we continue to configure our priorities, as a community, around a reflexive, mean- spirited and frankly stupid hostility to cultural spending, the filled potholes will allow a lot of very smooth one-way trips out of this cold, efficient province.”
That's perfect. Reminds me of Yves-François Blanchet's line, "I am not certain that oil and gas qualify to define a culture." Take heed, Alberta separatists: if you want to be a nation, give more money to artists!
 
Last edited:
After over 30 years, probably time to update the entrance signage. While I don't dislike the current ones as much as some, they do seem very staid and boring as well as of course dated ... of a city living in past glories.

I hope this is not the image we are intending to convey.
 
I'm not sure whether it would be a wise idea to make Gateway and Calgary Trail two-way south of 51 Avenue. Perhaps have a single lane the other direction running along the business sections, something like Stony Plain Road west of 175 Street.

Otherwise, I think the connector to 91 Street would be great.
 
Last edited:

Back
Top