News   Apr 03, 2020
From the Editor: A Message to Our Readers
 8.3K     3 
News   Apr 02, 2020
Topping Off March 2020: What's Hot on SkyriseEdmonton
 9.5K     0 
News   Apr 02, 2020
News Roundup for April 2, 2020
 3.1K     0 

Old Royal Alberta Museum

kcantor

kcantor

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Jul 20, 2020
Messages
1,684
Reaction score
6,015
Location
Edmonton, Alberta
Apologies if there is already a thread somewhere but I have looked and can’t find one…

I originally posted this to the Historic Edmonton and Northern Alberta's Facebook private group page and was asked to make it public so I'm reposting it here:

Tommy Banks and I once "blue skied" backfilling the old Royal Alberta Museum with a retirement/seniors facility for artists and musicians who can no longer practice their craft and who have no savings or pensions… I think there’s still an endowment with the Edmonton Community Foundation although I don’t know how large it is.

The thought was for residences on the main floor where natural light could be introduced and studio/rehearsal spaces that don’t need/want natural light could be located in the lower levels. The residents could stay active teaching/tutoring those young artists and performers using the studios.

The existing theatre and gift shop and cafe would stay in supportive use, perhaps complimented by an outdoor sculpture gallery.

The project could also likely support a recording studio and possibly even a small sound stage in the lower levels.

I also think there would be an interesting symmetry on the site with Government House if there was a large indigenous component sharing a location large enough to hold pow wows that stretches from the two buildings down the bank to the North Saskatchewan River.

Photo credit to CBC

IMG_0902.jpeg
 
kcantor said:
Apologies if there is already a thread somewhere but I have looked and can’t find one…

I originally posted this to the Historic Edmonton and Northern Alberta's Facebook private group page and was asked to make it public so I'm reposting it here:

Tommy Banks and I once "blue skied" backfilling the old Royal Alberta Museum with a retirement/seniors facility for artists and musicians who can no longer practice their craft and who have no savings or pensions… I think there’s still an endowment with the Edmonton Community Foundation although I don’t know how large it is.

The thought was for residences on the main floor where natural light could be introduced and studio/rehearsal spaces that don’t need/want natural light could be located in the lower levels. The residents could stay active teaching/tutoring those young artists and performers using the studios.

The existing theatre and gift shop and cafe would stay in supportive use, perhaps complimented by an outdoor sculpture gallery.

The project could also likely support a recording studio and possibly even a small sound stage in the lower levels.

I also think there would be an interesting symmetry on the site with Government House if there was a large indigenous component sharing a location large enough to hold pow wows that stretches from the two buildings down the bank to the North Saskatchewan River.

Photo credit to CBC

View attachment 594605
Click to expand...

This is a great idea and also the UCP are the last gov’t party that would ever support something like this. They’d raze the entire side of the valley for a lump of coal before ever considering something like this.
 
I walked by today and the stone looks is really really rough shape...obviously due to several years of no maintenance and care.

Not a stone expert, but are we certain that everything on the exterior can be fully restored or did the gap in care make it difficult to salvage?
 
scyeg said:
This is a great idea and also the UCP are the last gov’t party that would ever support something like this. They’d raze the entire side of the valley for a lump of coal before ever considering something like this.
Click to expand...
This is an interesting idea, it already has the theatre and display space and there may be Federal or other money available for housing .

The fundamental problem is the UCP does not want to put much or any money into doing anything with this, but if someone had the money and a good idea, they actually might be happy to have them take it off their hands
 
Doesn't the Orange Hub (old MacEwan JP campus), already perform this function. except, of course, housing.
 
Last edited:
This may be stupid question, but would it be worth taking another run at this or propose some other reimagine type project? Take it high profile now that the proposed demolition is in the news and a bit of a hot topic.
 
^

The building is most definitely worth it.

For those that have tried in the past however, the answer was always “it hasn’t been declared surplus yet” followed by “we can’t single source the disposition of government assets”.

There was an early RFEOI but it was designed not to facilitate anything but their own plans to do nothing. So things drift along and the asset deteriorates - some might say intentionally - to the point they think demolition is justified “because remediation and abatement would be too costly”.

And here we are…

It would be nice if the current attention does change things.
 
kcantor said:
^

The building is most definitely worth it.

For those that have tried in the past however, the answer was always “it hasn’t been declared surplus yet” followed by “we can’t single source the disposition of government assets”.

There was an early RFEOI but it was designed not to facilitate anything but their own plans to do nothing. So things drift along and the asset deteriorates - some might say intentionally - to the point they think demolition is justified “because remediation and abatement would be too costly”.

And here we are…

It would be nice if the current attention does change things.
Click to expand...
Yes, sometimes I think our real city slogan should be Make something Languish, we have more than one government here that does that. Again the usual, let the assets deteriorate and then tear them down.
 
www.google.com

Edmonton developer, architect push to save Old Royal Alberta Museum | CityNews Edmonton

An Edmonton-based developer and architect are launching renewed efforts to save the Old Royal Alberta Museum.
www.google.com www.google.com

"Both Beljan and Škopac have already been talking with the government for two years about repurposing the museum. Talks stalled out and plans were pushed aside.

“Nobody talked to us after. There wasn’t a discussion. There wasn’t a can we continue this conversation,” explained Beljan."
 
Last edited:
This does not sound promising at all. It seems like Beljan is making this public as a last-ditch effort to force an uncooperative government's hand by encouraging public backlash. The problem is, I don't think the UCP cares.

Both Beljan and Škopac have already been talking with the government for two years about repurposing the museum. Talks stalled out and plans were pushed aside.

“Nobody talked to us after. There wasn’t a discussion. There wasn’t a can we continue this conversation,” explained Beljan.

Demolishing the building remains the top option for the province estimated to cost between $28-40 million. The province says renovating or repurposing could cost three times or four times more.

A spokesperson for the Ministry of Infrastructure told CityNews, “We cannot comment on the proposal from Beljan Developments as it is still being reviewed. Alberta’s government remains committed to redeveloping the site into a family-friendly park and green space as announced in August.”
Click to expand...
 
TAS said:
www.google.com

Edmonton developer, architect push to save Old Royal Alberta Museum | CityNews Edmonton

An Edmonton-based developer and architect are launching renewed efforts to save the Old Royal Alberta Museum.
www.google.com www.google.com

"Both Beljan and Škopac have already been talking with the government for two years about repurposing the museum. Talks stalled out and plans were pushed aside.

“Nobody talked to us after. There wasn’t a discussion. There wasn’t a can we continue this conversation,” explained Beljan."
Click to expand...
Not an uncommon "discussion" and not restricted to the old RAM or to Ivan and Vedran... :(
 
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top