Mod edit: Please keep things civil folks and focus on the issue instead of the person. I've intentionally edited this post.
Ian, WEM might've dealt a big blow to downtown's retail, but at 1.5M in the mero area, I wasn't what killed it (although I dare say it is not dead just yet, rather on life-support). South Edmonton Common and the likes of it are just as responsible, if not more, than WEM, for this.
Again, while the Downtown CORE has a lower population than I would like, the central neighborhoods are, by far, the densest and most populated, (Garneau and Oliver being two of the 3 most dense neighborhoods in Alberta). Also, the notion of convenient and short drive is lost on me, when you think that for more than half of the city, the closest (and only) Ikea is probably a 20 to 30 minute drive, unless you're going on a weekend. As for groceries, I think we'll be decently served with a Safeway (Oliver), the Save On (Grandin/Downtown), Sobeys (Oliver Square's store is renovating and will likely become a Sobeys) and two Loblaws City Market (Brewery and Ice Districts), especially considering that 3 of the 5 will be served by the Valley Line West and two of them are in very dense and populated areas). I would love to see something pop up south of Jasper, around 103/104 streets, though I agree that, as of now, there's probably not going to be enough demand for it, especially with a Walmart in the works for Kingsway Mall.
Urban economics, especially on the retail market, can work the other way around, and we've seen examples of that in much poorer, smaller and more isolated cities than Edmonton. You can induce demand with the right supply incentives, but for that you need people to stop whining about stuff and actually DO something. That goes for developers, businesses, the council, the mayor... Hell, Costco @ 149 St is ALWAYS stupidly busy and the traffic is HORRIBLE to get there most of the time, coming from DT and Oliver... I bet they also take in customers from most central neighborhoods north of the river. With it eventually closing (with the Yellowhead project, that's just a matter of time...), there's no space to put one closer to Downtown (because the closest ones will be either in Granville or South Edmonton Common)? You really don't think that it would help attract people to the core, make it friendlier to families (that shop there, A LOT, much more than singles or younger couples)? You really believe that having some of the stuff we only have in the suburbs wouldn't put the developers to think that maybe, people will be more interested in living there?