Romanov
Active Member
Why was this torn down?
Why was this torn down?
Because it's the most Edmonton thing you can do?Why was this torn down?
|
Respectfully I would disagree. It's been the opportunity of the century. Downtown Calgary's biggest flaw was that was too office space heavy. Suddenly a pile of buildings (31 buildings) that someone else paid to build, come free to convert, and as a city you only need to throw in some subsidy money to get the conversions over the finish line and instantly add 4,000 new residential units. It's a gift from the heavens.I'd rather spend grant money first on new construction and buildings first and office conversions last tbh. I get that there's a property tax uplift for lower office vacancy rates, but the amount of money Calgary is throwing at conversions for the units they're getting seem underwhelming. I get it's a different problem and we have a glut of parking and empty lots that makes it easier for us to focus on new builds, but cost-benefit for tax dollars seems better for new builds?
So far for office conversions, we're getting:
- Phipps Mckinnon Conversion. (100 units)
- Financial Building Conversion (33 units)
- McKenney Building Conversion (33 units)
- CN Tower Conversion (344 units)
- The Standard on Jasper Conversion (???)
- WSP Place Conversion (???
This is true. Edmonton, and other cities have done this in the past, Edmonton was one of the first. In all fairness to Calgary, office space rates have never been low enough to warrant conversions, so it's unlikely any one had considered the option. To Calgary's credit, they've taken a lemon and turned it into lemonade. It's been far more successful than anticipated. It should also be noted that not all conversions are using subsidies. Doing so many conversions in such a short time, with the help of a subsidy is why Calgary is suddenly the hotspot for office conversions.Edmonton was encouraging and doing residential conversions downtown decades ago, before it was even thought of in Calgary, and actually we still are. Although not with the emergency level of public money that they are having to put in now in response to an office vacancy rate that is still considerably higher than ours. I have to laugh if they think they discovered this great idea, when in fact it has been happening elsewhere for a long time.
Is that part of MacEwan?Job Type
Major Development Permit
External ID
651049466-002
Location
10700 - 104 AVENUE NW Plan 2121375 Blk 20 Lot 102
Description
Alteration of (an) existing building(s), Exterior Alteration, Change of Use / Interior Alterations
Applicant
CHANDOS CONSTRUCTION LTD
Development Category
Date Created
March 18, 2026
Status
Intake Review
Development Permit Decision Date
Development Permit Decision not yet made*
Development Permit Decision Date Published on this Webpage
Neighbourhood
DOWNTOWN
Then let the announcements begin!I think it will be popular. One of the last catalyst projects in the downtown plan to be realized and people have been lobbying for it for years.
Then let the announcements begin!![]()
$7 mil is about the going rate for 5 inner city single family homes in Calgary, for neighborhoods in around the core. Maybe a bit exaggerated, but the point being $7 million isn’t much in the grand scheme of housing costs.$7 million for 5 inner city homes, is $1.4 million each. I don't think houses in the inner city here are anywhere near that, although I don't know about Calgary. It seems high, but perhaps that is the case.
Calgary is the hot spot for office conversions mostly because of the millions of square feet of empty office space. Both our vacancy rate and the actual amount of vacant space here is far lower.
Yes, they are trying to make lemonade from lemons, but the situation here is really not the same. I am not against copying what works elsewhere, but the circumstances here are different and more conversions seem to happening here now without public subsidy. Many landlords do realize, there is no incentive for an old building to remain empty for years while costs still have to be paid and so come up with solutions on their own.




