Beltline_B
Senior Member
Maclab, don't let your hate on for Calgary get in the way of forward thinkingDon't want to a Debbie Downer but no high speed rail is happening in AB under Saddlebags Smitty or Nenshi when he takes over the province....let's keep up with current events and realize that $27B of projected debt for the next 3 years is not gonna allow a train for rich Asians to get to Banff quicker....let us please end this foolish discussion....especially when the new BoyChild Mayor to the South is already complaining about YYC'ers paying too much in taxes...
This is 100% the path needed.As for HSR affecting YEG. It probably won't have much of an effect. Those who go YEG->YYC->* will keep doing so. Those who drive from YEG to YYC will keep doing so. some might take HSR to YYC, but it won't be a large amount. IMO, nothing changes for YEG.
As for HSR to YYC-Banff, I agree with others, it's not nice but not needed. Start within conventional rail, get the system in place, and upgrade to HSR later. Some sort of rail service is needed though. The traffic volumes are increasing every year, and every time an international flight is added to YYC, it adds more tourists to Banff.
I know what you mean. I imagine it'll make the towns of Banff and Canmore far more busier, and that would please the segment of tourists that are from the - 'more shopping and restaurants the better' crowd. Side bus routes to places around the parks will get somewhat busier also.If so, it may become easier to get to Banff, but the rail service may end up making the congestion there worse and ultimately making it a less desirable location for those who do not like overly crowded tourist destinations.
For tourists or locals like myself who use the Kananaskis and Banff parks regularly, but don't go the tourist spots, there are plenty of options, and thankfully they wouldn't be served by rail. It'll be mostly the way it is today, but be somewhat busier in some places. I mean the thing with the parks is that, the hotspots are getting crazy busy, but there are literally thousands of places to go where there isn't a single soul, and hundreds to go where they are slightly or moderately busy. It's a scale of 0 people to 1000's of people.
Anywhooo back to YEG related discussion.




