The Shift | 113.08m | 38s | Edgar | MCM Partnership

What do you think of this project?

  • Total voters
    35
David A said:
Also, I agree we have great potential although they mostly stopped building brownstones 100 years ago, so I wouldn't be too hopeful on that. Particularly as recreating an older style really seems beyond most Edmonton builders.
Click to expand...
I get the sense that it's generally rare for these sorts of buildings to be built anywhere except where rents or purchase prices are much higher. The sort of brick-clad former tenement housing you see in the LES (for example) would never get built as working-class housing today.

I would guess this is largely due to an increase through time in the cost of labor (i.e. construction wages)? But I've also heard it said that e.g. masonry is much more expensive in Alberta than eastern Canada, in which case we should be able to find ways to bring that cost down, perhaps through concerted effort in training/attracting workers?
 
constance_chlore said:
I get the sense that it's generally rare for these sorts of buildings to be built anywhere except where rents or purchase prices are much higher. The sort of brick-clad former tenement housing you see in the LES (for example) would never get built as working-class housing today.

I would guess this is largely due to an increase through time in the cost of labor (i.e. construction wages)? But I've also heard it said that e.g. masonry is much more expensive in Alberta than eastern Canada, in which case we should be able to find ways to bring that cost down, perhaps through concerted effort in training/attracting workers?
Click to expand...
I feel part of the problem is we don't have enough construction workers familiar with the materials and techniques, so yes training and attracting them from where they do, is a good idea as is bring costs down.

I find in Edmonton at least the word brownstones now sometimes seems to be used as a bait and switch for people to promote projects that probably end up looking nothing like what we hope or imagine they would.
 
David A said:
I feel part of the problem is we don't have enough construction workers familiar with the materials and techniques, so yes training and attracting them from where they do, is a good idea as is bring costs down.

I find in Edmonton at least the word brownstones now sometimes seems to be used as a bait and switch for people to promote projects that probably end up looking nothing like what we hope or imagine they would.
Click to expand...
I'm hopeful that NAIT's upcoming expansion will help build this kind of capacity.

I haven't heard anyone really use the term 'brownstone' in Edmonton, but certainly the two condos in Queen Alex called Brownstone are nowhere near the quality of an actual brownstone.
 
It seems that Edmonton still -- after 60 odd years -- has too much of the wild west-north-west expansionism in its veins. A build what benefits us vs a build that helps them on the part of about 1/2+ of the City's developers. If we keep pressing "do better" it will begin to sink in (barring that the taste of some resides somewhere akin to the soles of their shoes).
 
Barnaby said:
Checking out Nexbrick now because of @archited

Cool product I guess. Hopefully someone local uses it in the WH district.
Click to expand...
Nexbrick could become popular. Nexbrick may not have all of the thermal properties that makes solid brick desirable but it has the appearance of solid brick without the high labour cost associated with constructing a solid brick veneer. Further, the common problem of repointing mortar is likely reduced if not eliminated entirely.
 
Preliminary designs:

1772663354733.png

1772663359725.png

1772663370034.png

1772663378829.png

1772663386276.png
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top